I was going to get a Marmot Precip before we tackled the Pennine Way and had tried one on but decided that my current waterpoof would be good for one more year if I reproofed it. I was wrong! I got very wet through just before Hawes and ended up buying a new one there ( no Marmot Precip), so I still haven’t got one unfortunately! But it was comfortable, fitted well and the reviews were good.