Reading this thread (been a busy week, just catching up) - not sure what Maggot said which is rubbing people the wrong way?
The question was 'what would you want to see?', so by its very nature you end up with a wish list. People are fully aware there are limitations behind getting all this done, principally time, editorial and photography skills, and actual motivation to do so. For what it's worth, I really enjoy all the videos and trip reports posted here and never think 'oh if only they did x it'd be so much better' - I just like people sharing their love for the outdoors in a way which makes them happy.
Brian's original horse-shoe post was compelling and he's really not very far from upping the quality for v little effort, which I guess is why he asked. I wouldn't worry about the expectations at all, personally when I click a link I expect nothing - if it's in HD or above I'm immediately happy with some pretty scenery, the audio needs to be obnoxious for it to bother. Think most are the same? You understand you're getting a home movie of sorts.