Maybe, but for me it fitted so well and was a joy to carry. I used it first to hike and camp the Pennine Way. In the end, about three years later I'd almost worn it out, scuffing on the ground and so on. I don't do that now, I'm more careful. I thought it was a good design though, nicely lightweight which is why I am pleased with my Exos 48L now, again light and all of the compartments are in the right place. Mine never did leak, I just used to throw on an elasticated waterproof cover and it worked fine. All things come to an end and we then move on!